Malcolm Gladwell, well-known journalist and author, grew up in Canada and always pondered the difference in his country and the U.S. regarding the issue of guns—or maybe more to the point, gun control. He set out to explore the cultural differences in our two nations when it comes to firearms in his latest book The American Way of Killing: The Invention of an Epidemic.
As the U.S. mindlessly carries on with 45,000 gun deaths a year (a third suicide, another third accidents, the rest assorted crimes and murder), in extreme contrast Canada’s firearm deaths are at 221 annually. And in both countries, police officers carry firearms.
The U.S. has more guns than citizens: 430 million firearms for a population of 390 million. In contrast, our neighbor to the north has around 10 to 14 million guns among a much smaller population of 41.5 million. Note: Canada has more people than guns.
All the other countries on earth are similar to Canada with extremely low incidents of shooting deaths while the U.S. leads the world in tens of thousands of mostly senseless and not even politically-motivated gun deaths every year.
Speaking to comedian Bill Maher on Real Time, Gladwell cannot fathom why we modern Americans continue to endure senseless shootings on a daily basis—at schools, shopping centers, churches, synagogues, parks, parties, homes, businesses, courts, newsrooms, hospitals for Pete’s sake, etc., etc.
The American love of guns is as unique as our founding. Timing is everything, and guns a-plenty have been around since Jamestown. I’m referring to the Western Europeans who sailed across the Atlantic Ocean to build new lives in what they called America.
One explanation for ‘the way Americans are’ goes back to the early 17th century and the settlement by Puritans. Though a relatively small populace at the time, mostly from England to escape brutal persecution for their strict and unwavering religious beliefs, to this modern day and century puritanical beliefs remain embedded in many aspects of American life. One is the overturning of a woman’s right to abortion. Perhaps congressional prayer breakfasts and prayers before government meetings also stem from our Puritan ancestry. (Not to forget big hang ups about sex and its lone purpose: reproduction only.)
Puritans were keen on public display of ‘sinners’ such as placing a drunkard in standing stocks at the town square and allowing children to throw rotten vegetables at their faces. This punishment could go on a few days. Punitive action for those whose moral failings so offended this high and mighty lot is another modern-day American philosophy. Our culture treats the accused as guilty until proven innocent, even if our laws say otherwise, and our belief in corporal (physical) and capital (deadly) punishment.
Americans like to see people who did wrong get punished. Movie and video games reflect American culture. Then there’s our romanticizing of our history’s Wild West cowboy—a period shared, experienced and understood by no other culture on earth. These stories remained very popular in the early days of the moving pictures. Then no one held their ears as the talkies kept the Westerns going accompanied by lotsa loud gun shootin’ between cowboys and Natives. It was to Americans entertaining—even to Arnold Ziffle, the TV-watching pig on Green Acres.
Crime in America, though remarkably reduced compared to previous decades, is another reason for all the gun ownership including families who own numerous powerful firearms. Congress allowed the assault-rifle ban to go nonrenewed in the late 20th century—and BANG!! Look at all the daily mass shootings that have occurred directly due to this purposefully reckless oversight by our elected government.
Guns, guns, guns. That is the credo of our land, our country, our territory. In comparison to ‘the right to bear arms’ being guaranteed in our Constitution, Canada has strict federal laws whereby guns are a regulated privilege and not an assumed right of the people.
Congress allowed the masses to obtain military-style rifles due to the white-people concern about home invasions and gangs—which were using machine guns in the 1990s for their drive-by shootings, gang initiations of shooting anonymous citizens.
We all witnessed it on TV—whether a news report or a cop-and-law show. Distinguishing between news and fiction has become … unimportant to modern Americans.
Not so in Canada. This is how efficient Canadian government works: Years ago when a school shooting occurred, the entire nation put in place laws to prevent this tragedy from happening again. One of the laws was ‘netiquette’—school education for using the internet from 4th grade to 8th grade with a certificate at completion that permitted young people to go online unsupervised. This issue was the root cause for the individual who shot up a school in Canada.
Canada is a nation of unlocked doors
How?!!! They can’t be serious! Americans have been locking their doors for generations now, probably started when every home was getting a television set in the ’50s. Our locked doors have less to do with fear of burglary than fear of assault. And our other credo: Better safe than sorry.
Americans love comeuppance. It’s one of our traits, unendearing as it is. Goes back to our punitive nature.
One other cultural phenomenon that distinguishes the U.S. from every nation on earth is the reported number of sociopaths we produce. In The Sociopath Next Door, the statistic is at 20 percent to 25 percent: 1 in 5 or 1 in 4 Americans is a sociopath. In Japan, for comparison, as well as most other nations, the statistic is more like 2 percent of their populations; perhaps the same for Canada. Sociopaths do not care about anybody except themselves. They enjoy throwing psychological ‘monkey wrenches’ into their families and places of employment. They don’t particularly care if they are found out and serve prison time either. Sounds like anyone we know? Maybe more than one person in our lives?
So here we are. It’s the end of 2026. America is somehow still around, a wacky combination of democracy and republic. And pretty much everyone can legally own guns (in some states no questions asked and allowed to carry guns in public), lock every window and door to their cars and abodes, install cameras surrounding large homes and businesses, watch more fictional TV and play shooter video games with the color red spurting so you know you shot a character, condone and award violent movies, and interestingly enough don’t much go to church like they used to. And we don’t really like singing This Land is Your Land anymore either. Americans are going through one of our brutal kick-the-immigrants-out phases. (It’ll pass. It has to, duh, because immigrants are good for business. Always have been.)
Our Puritan heritage also is why some states now require Bible teachings in public schools, post the Ten Commandments in every classroom, and canceled courses like journalism and banned after-school activities like yoga. The Puritans, known for seeking no pleasure in this presumed miserable existence on earth, is why families still will not teach their children anything about sex and pregnancy prevention and those same families work tirelessly to ensure sex education is not permitted in schools.
If Gladwell really wants to understand Americans, as we all know and accept ourselves to be, let me suggest reading and/or watching The Crucible. This critically important award-winning play by American Arthur Miller provides great insight into puritanical beliefs and practices especially when left unchecked by others whose Christian faith and practice were less severe. After all, the Puritans were keen on seeking out the devil in their fellow man, presuming the devil will take over a human being if the heart is not pure and thoughts off God for a second. The Puritans of Salem, Massachusetts, hanged a few hundred women (and a couple of men) for being witches. The condemned were usually landowners, and the powerful among the Puritan communities wanted it for prosperity. Ah yes, the American dream even way back then.
Though our Puritan ancestors may be rolling in their New England graves as we’ve strayed a lot from their teachings, Canadians remain content in their lovingkindness and collective multi-ethnic culture of peace and calm that comes from their universal trust in everybody else. (Can you believe it?)
